Limited Time Offer: 25% Off
Small Business Management

Fleet Management by Excel Spreadsheet: Pros, Cons, and Tips

Spreadsheets are low-cost and easy to use, but when it comes to tracking and managing your fleet, you’re likely getting what you pay for. To help you determine whether this ‘free’ option is the right one for your small business, we’ve outlined the pros and cons of using fleet management spreadsheets, plus our best advice for making the most of Excel.

The Pros of Tracking Your Fleet via Spreadsheet

Tracking fleets with spreadsheets may not be our first choice, but it does come with a few perks.

It’s free or low-cost

Spreadsheets don’t cost any money upfront. You can simply spend some time brainstorming the specific data you need to collect and create a master spreadsheet that tracks it all.

It’s relatively easy

If you’ve got an eye for detail, dedicated staff, and lots of time to put into fleet management and tracking, you won’t have any trouble mastering the spreadsheet method.

Data entry is simple

If you have even a baseline understanding of Microsoft Excel, you’ll likely find that inputting your data into a spreadsheet comes easily.

Something is better than nothing

You need data and information on your fleet if you’re going to make reliable business decisions. If the only alternative to using a spreadsheet is not tracking your fleet at all, jump into fleet spreadsheets headfirst!

How To Improve Your Fleet Management Spreadsheet

If you have to use a spreadsheet to manage your fleet, make it as reliable and objective as possible by putting these tips to work for you:

Collect more trip data

Use your spreadsheet to track more than just mileage. 

When used correctly, a fleet management spreadsheet can tell you things like whether or not your fleet is being well-utilized, how much each individual vehicle is being used, and which trips and routes are most efficient.

To make better use of your spreadsheet, be sure to create columns for at least the following:

  • Trip date
  • Destination
  • Driver
  • Trip start time
  • Trip end time

Create one worksheet per vehicle

The ideal fleet tracking spreadsheet has one worksheet per vehicle, which lets you easily reference each car’s history and usage at a glance. If you’re Excel-savvy, you can even set up each page using formulas that produce vehicle-specific reports on things like mileage, expenses, and fuel efficiency.

Use maintenance & payment schedules

Every vehicle in your fleet will have its own maintenance schedule, and possibly, its own insurance and registration payment dates. If these dates come and go without action, your fleet could suffer from poor vehicle health and expired paperwork that keeps your drivers off the road. Tracking maintenance and payment dates for each car will make you much more likely to remember and act on them.

Track driver performance

Driver performance is an important variable in your business. Make very intentional notes on how many hours each team member is driving, which vehicles they use, and how much fuel their trips require. Be sure to document the dates and details of any accidents, tickets, and infractions, too.

Bottom line: Spreadsheets definitely aren’t ideal for business, but if you have the time and you’re completely committed, it’s possible to make them work.

How Fleet Management Spreadsheets Hold Small Businesses Back

The thing most small business owners don’t realize is that even though spreadsheets are technically free, the constant data entry and ongoing management they require puts a huge strain on both human and financial resources — and most small businesses feel the weight of that requirement very quickly.

Here are a few unexpected ways that your “free” fleet spreadsheet might be holding your small business back:

Heavy admin time

Choosing a fleet management spreadsheet that properly tracks all of the data your business needs means choosing to put a lot of time into data entry. And as a small business owner, you know better than anyone that time is money. 

You have a small, nimble team, and you need to squeeze every hour out of every person and every vehicle. In order to maintain a spreadsheet that functions, tracks, and reports the way you need it to, you’ll be working all kinds of overtime or paying for an assistant to help you. Either way, it’s worth reflecting in advance on whether or not this ‘free’ option is a sustainable one.

Bothersome logbooks

Managing your fleet in an Excel spreadsheet puts more demands on your staff to self-report using logbooks and other less-than-reliable documents. 

Logbooks are tedious, easy to forget, and hard to maintain, which means there’s a good chance they’re inaccurate even on the best of days. Not only does this bog down your drivers who are likely to hate using them, but it could also mean that your business is letting invaluable data slip away.

Inaccurate data

Most fleet management spreadsheets are created in-house, updated referencing hand-written logbooks, and maintained by multiple people. Whether it’s due to human error, missing documents, or just bad penmanship, this makes them likely to be highly inaccurate! 

Your business needs clear, reliable data that you can use to make informed, strategic decisions. The reality is that with a shared file that’s easily tweaked, updated, saved, copied, and changed, you may never have that.

Limited reporting

Another downside to a homemade tracking spreadsheet is limited functionality in the way of reporting. Excel can produce decent reports, but only if the spreadsheet is created with the end report in mind.

Limited reporting means more hurdles to overcome monthly, as team members scramble to pull the data they need for accounting and other purposes. This can be a particularly time-consuming issue during tax season, when you need data to back up claims of revenue, expenses, and deductions.

The ROI of Fleet Management Software

Contrary to popular belief, ‘free’ fleet spreadsheets come at a cost. Human resources get wasted as valuable staff hours go down the drain and dedicated drivers grow wary of tedious timesheets and reactive tracking. Financial resources take a hit when faulty data collection and low-level reporting cost tax deductions and additional staff time. 

Our advice: Save yourself time, money, and headaches with fleet management software designed for small businesses, like yours.

Introducing: Force by Mojio

Force by Mojio is a fleet GPS tracking software, hardware, and app. It can help you manage your fleet, hold your drivers accountable, track your expenses, and increase driver safety. No detail goes undocumented, and nothing is left to chance.

With features like GPS tracking, vehicle fuel and health alerts, driver safety scores, and speeding alerts, Force tracks and manages your fleet with complete accuracy. It gives you the detailed trip and driver information you need to make the most of your company’s resources, and the transparency you need to make clear and strategic business moves.

Running a small business is hard. Force by Mojio makes it easier. Start your free trial today!